This morning I stood in our back garden with not a stitch on. Not that I’m an exhibitionist, mind. This would be a few minutes before three and, other than the light cast by a waning moon, quite dark. All honest souls lay slumbering else tossing and turning but I, woken by Tebay’s barking, had let him out for a wee.
So there’s me, as nature intended, pondering with mixed feelings the fact I could have stood like this till dawn, with ne’er a shiver or goose-bump to remind me I’m not on some Greek or Goan beach but in the east midlands of an outpost of Western Europe famed as much for its cold damp climate as for its terrible cuisine.
A few hours later, showered and dressed, I read this on the World Socialist Website:
The disaster of global warming will continue until a movement is built to stop it in the European and international working class, in opposition to the entire ruling elite … Youth and workers seeking to fight global warming must draw the necessary conclusions from the ruling elite’s refusal to take action and its suicidal drive towards a new world war. Overcoming these threats to civilization require ending the anarchic profit system and its replacement with a scientifically planned, socialist global economy. This requires building a mass anti-war and socialist movement in the working class to take control of world economy out of the hands of the financial aristocracy, and subordinate it to social need, not private profit.
I disagree. Not because of its diagnosis, with which I fully concur, but because its remedy seems a textbook case of magical thinking. For one thing the working class of the global north has lost – with the insufficient exception of those transport and communications sectors which, as Mick Lynch has reminded Britain, can’t be outsourced to the global south – its muscle. For another, the ‘vanguard’ tendencies of the far left, on which WSWS and its Socialist Equality Party hosts can be placed, are silent on the small matter of how the modern capitalist state, armed to the teeth and equipped with tools of surveillance and counterinsurgency capacities beyond the wildest dreams of 20th century totalitarianisms, can be overthrown by force from within.
This leads directly to a secondary bone of c. with WSWS (which btw I regard as the best of the West’s ultraleftist organs). Where it deems China just another capitalist nation, I – as evidenced in my post of two days ago, Why read Michael Hudson? – do not. As I put it in that post:
If humanity has any hope of avoiding the various forms of disaster to which the venal ineptitude of its ruling classes have brought us, that hope lies with the rise of China and its challenge to the reckless insanity of a dollarised world.
But I like to think I’m not one for throwing baby out with bathwater. There’s a good reason why, in spite of a few pretty fundamental differences, I check in once or twice a week to see what WSWS has to say. Its post today on global warming is a case in point. Other than its tiresomely predictable rabbit-from-a-hat finale, cited earlier, I find it an admirably lucid statement of where humanity is at in respect of the climatological front of capitalism’s war on Nature.
Worst-ever drought devastates Europe amid capitalism’s climate crisis
From Britain to the Balkans, a record-breaking drought is devastating Europe. Over 60 percent of the European Union and Great Britain face drought conditions, according to the European Drought Observatory, in what one EU Commission scientist called Europe’s worst drought in 500 years. Major rivers and lakes are drying up, farmers are facing unprecedented crop failures, and energy supplies are collapsing amid unprecedented heat and lack of rainfall.
The summer of 2022, which broke records for heat, wildfires and now drought in Europe, has made clear the urgent necessity of dealing with global climate change. It has now reached such a vast extent that, without prompt and large-scale action, it will threaten basic functions of society critical to human life—such as the ability to provide water, food, electricity, and safe housing.
This summer’s extreme drought was caused by record-low precipitation in Europe this year and successive heatwaves, including the July heatwave that shattered temperature records. Extreme heat and drought also led to record wildfires, with 615,341 hectares burned this year across Europe—the highest-ever figure for mid-August. The drought is disrupting key food and energy supplies, already undermined by the NATO-Russia war in Ukraine, driving prices for essential goods even higher amid the ongoing inflation crisis.
On the Rhine River, barges are carrying goods at 25 percent capacity due to low water levels. Water levels are now at 40 centimeters but are forecast to fall to around 30cm, which may completely halt transport on the river. Such stoppages in 2018 cost the German economy an estimated €5 billion.
Last week, France forced its nuclear power plants, which produce 70 percent of its electricity, to operate at reduced capacity: releasing high-temperature coolant water into rivers that are at record low levels is an ecological hazard. Amid the ongoing energy crisis, however, the French energy agency now has ordered the plants to return to full capacity, whatever the resulting damage to the environment, including plant and animal life. Of France’s 96 mainland departments, 86 are on drought alert. The Loire River, France’s second-largest, can be crossed on foot along much of its length.
The water level on the Danube River, Europe’s longest, is currently 43 centimeters, the lowest since records began. In Serbia, Bulgaria and Romania, dredging efforts are underway to keep the river navigable for barges, which are crucial for Balkan food and energy supplies. In southern Germany, the river’s water temperature exceeded 25°C and is expected to reach 27°C by the end of the month, the same temperature as the Caribbean Sea.
Across Europe, fish are threatened by record high water temperatures and low oxygen content. The entire fish stock of Conopljankso reservoir in Serbia died after it completely dried up.
The surface of the Oder River, running between Poland and Germany, is now all but covered in dead fish. While Polish officials have contested reports of heavy industrial contamination of the river, it is clear that as the river’s water volume plummeted to record lows, concentrations of industrial pollutants have skyrocketed.
European farmers are facing massive crop failures, with production of key grains down 30 to 40 percent in Italy and nearly 20 percent in France. Spain’s olive oil crop, which counts for nearly half of world exports, is expected to be one-quarter of the average produced over the last five years.
In northern Italy’s Po Valley, 60 percent of this year’s crop has been lost as farmers have been unable to use local rivers for crop irrigation. This has already caused at least €6.2 billion in damage. The region, which produces 30 to 40 percent of Italy’s food supply, has seen virtually no rain this year. Near the Po estuary, water levels are so low that salt water from the Adriatic Sea flowed 30 kilometers upstream, killing crops near the river’s banks that had so far survived the drought.
Drinking water supplies are critically low in every city along the Po Valley, including Milan and Turin. Water levels in lakes in the region are also at historical lows, including the popular tourist destination of Lake Garda in northern Italy, which has almost completely dried up.
Even Europe’s northernmost and wettest regions are suffering. Low water levels in Norway’s reservoirs are reducing its ability to produce hydroelectric power. This has led to warnings that it may have to cut energy exports, further exacerbating the energy crisis caused by NATO threats to refuse to pay for Russian gas and Russian threats to cut off supplies. Eight UK regions face drought conditions, including the capital, London.
These events point to the urgent necessity of an internationally-coordinated campaign to halt and address the consequences of global warming. Trillions of euros must be invested in high technology, key infrastructure, irrigation technology, clean energy generation, food security programs, and other initiatives to ensure that the globe remains habitable for humanity.
Carrying this out requires a direct assault on the capitalist system, and the wealth and privileges of its corrupt financial aristocracy. Trillions of euros were found overnight amid the stock market crash that followed the outbreak of the COVID-19 pandemic. Yet this wealth went not to eliminate the virus, which has since then claimed over 1.6 million lives in Europe alone, or to fund critical infrastructure investments, but to bail out a tiny elite of wealthy investors who answer to no one.
As with the pandemic, the measures needed to combat global warming are well-known to scientists and government officials alike, but the international institutions of the capitalist nation-state system have failed to organize a coordinated response. Instead, they are plunging deeper into war. EU governments are pledging hundreds of billions of euros in military spending increases, preparing to escalate the war NATO is waging on Russia in Ukraine.
The current drought is exposing the much-vaunted 2015 Paris Accords, which seeks to limit global warming to 2°C from pre-industrial levels by the end of the century. Extreme weather caused by just 1.2°C of global warming is already catastrophic. Looking at the devastation in Europe today, one must ask: even if capitalist governments implemented the Paris Accords to the letter, how many of Europe’s rivers would run dry, and how much of its farmland would go barren?
The disaster of global warming will continue until a movement is built to stop it in the European and international working class, in opposition to the entire ruling elite. One need only look at the German Greens, supposedly the leading “ecological” party of Europe’s political establishment: they are leading the campaign for EU rearmament, while approving the return to use of highly polluting coal for power generation amid the wartime energy crisis.
Youth and workers seeking to fight global warming must draw the necessary conclusions from the ruling elite’s refusal to take action and its suicidal drive towards a new world war. Overcoming these threats to civilization require ending the anarchic profit system and its replacement with a scientifically planned, socialist global economy. This requires building a mass anti-war and socialist movement in the working class to take control of world economy out of the hands of the financial aristocracy, and subordinate it to social need, not private profit.
* * *
You have to be a conspiracy theorist to theorise about conspiracies.
The ‘Vanguard Tendencies’ of the far left are today reduced to teaming up with the once detested enemy – the police – to enforce the use of pronouns and gang up to deny anyone the right to contest the notion that biological men are really women.
Class politics having long been abandoned in favour of the atomised individualism of self-id and the pseudo-gibberish bollocks of ‘intersectionalism’. Even the so called ‘far left’ are Thatcherite now. Adherents to the puerile discourse of Rand – being the children who have never done a days real work in their entire lives that they are.
Who would’ve thought, the ‘far left’ are now willing useless idiots of ‘The Man.’ Enforcing stuff like this:
and thinking this is what being ‘right on’ is all about.
The notion that these entitled clueless numpties will ever be capable of dealing in any practical way with the issues highlighted in the featured WSWS article is a fore-lone hope.
They are, in their present iteration, part of the problem rather than part of the solution.
I love it when you go for the jugular. Bang on Dave!
Dear Dave, I really think you should have given me a health warning about the posts you you offered. I nearly had a fit when I read the first one about that PCSO and Brenda and things went downhill from there. Do you know if the PCSO had any legal right to verbally accost Brenda for putting a poster in her window? I know we have a new Bill demonizing anyone for any number of infractions related to free speech but surely that visit from the wannabe copper was way beyond the pale.
Just glad I don’t have my PSC poster up anymore(they faded completely)or I’d be in court for daring to side against apartheid and siding instead with the victims.
The world seems to have gone to hell in a handcart with everyone jumping on any bandwagon that comes their way with absolutely no regard for the consequences.
I can’t say anymore on which side I fall on the transgender/sexual/Xdresser/non gender/non sex issue in case I get carted off to jail. Someone may rat me out!
This might help with your key question Susan:
Depending on whether or not you want to continue experiencing regular fits you might want to spend a little time considering the option of subscribing to the Glinner updates on these matters via your email:
I’m advised gin, or similar, is helpful.
I’m tee total! If I’m going to fall off my chair and the wagon, it would probably be for a single malt. 🙂
Thanks for the hat tip to Graham Linehan.
Thanks Dave. I didn’t think it could be acceptable, but you never know these days. I just hope the PCSO is dismissed for abuse of her position and for harassment.
Of course if she wants to pay me a visit(I’ve met bent coppers before)she’ll get short thrift, but that is rather beside the point – I’m not the woman who has suffered what this woman has. Absolutely disgraceful behaviour from the PCSO. Verbal brutality from someone who isn’t even a police officer, whatever next.
Susan: Another link, just posted, you might find “interesting.”
One response to the “there’s two sides to every argument” platitude – except it’s more often privately thought than publicly aired – is to feign agreement.
“Yes, I see what you mean. Everybody takes sides with the Jews but nobody wants to hear the Nazi account of the Holocaust. It takes two to make a quarrel, you know …”
Incidentally, the drought/heat situation is a global one: China, India, the US etc are also affected. Apparently the El Nina phenomenon is involved. I found that out reading a Chinese newspaper – as far as the BBC are concerned only England is suffering. Putin is probably responsible, in their cock-eyed picture of the world. Or China. We really need to change our perspective and start seeing this planet as a whole and humanity as a single species with a mutual responsibility to one another and all other species. But in little England, expecting people just to see another European country as equal is obviously asking too much.
It’s a sobering observation, but perfectly on message.
Don’t know if you are interested in this but I do think that it is very important to put it out there so will leave you with the link.
It does explain a lot about the role of the agribusiness plan and the NWO fight for dominance.
Hope you are feeling better soon.
Thanks Susan. I’ve just finished reading it. I carp – for reasons too involved and detailed to go into here, and which in any case I suspect you share – at the occasional passages implying a moral equivalence between Russia and USA but this is an invaluable read. What’s more, it aligns neatly with the thrust of the Michael Hudson book, Destiny of Civilisation.
Speaking of which, and at the same time responding to your final sentence, I’m gathering my thoughts for the review which is to become, Why read Michael Hudson? Part 3. It’s slow work due to the fact the most pronounced symptom of my brush with Covid is now a need to sleep at least sixteen hours a day!