Europe: the madness of Kaja Kallas

17 Nov

*

For an icon of the European Commission’s high-handed lack of accountability, I look to ‘Queen Ursula’ von der Leyen; 1 for one of its capacity for staggering economic disingenuity to former Italian PM, ‘Super’ Mario Draghi. But for its seamless meld of hysteria with smug stupidity it’s another former PM, Estonia’s Kaja Kallas, who takes gold.

Russophobia is of course a sine qua non  of EC acceptability (more on that in the next two posts in this Europe mini-series) but few of its gob-smackingly entitled upper echelons are so flat out bonkers as to deny that the Soviet Union, with its twenty-seven million dead and Stalingrad the single most crucial turning point in WW2, was a major contributor (some, including yours truly, would say the major contributor) to the defeat of Hitler. Yet that’s precisely what Kaja Kallas did in September last year. Try this thirty-five second soundbyte:

*

Four days ago she was at it again. In another of her history master classes last Friday, she told the European Council summit in Dublin that:

We who might otherwise have cited Sweden’s Charles XII, 1708-9, Bonaparte, 1812, fourteen Western powers led by Britain and the USA, 1918-21, and the small matter of Hitler’s Barbarossa, 1941-4, may now give thanks to the magisterial Kaja for putting us straight on such benighted delusionality.

OK, ignorance and stupidity aren’t proof of madness. What has me questioning the sanity of the EU’s foreign policy chief is the majestic manner of her delivery of those things. It is  impressive. After all, as Bond villain Jonathan Pryce points out to Pierce Brosnan’s 007 in Tomorrow Never Dies, the difference between genius and insanity is success. On which criterion Kaja’s CV surely gets her triple gold.

Such is the degeneracy of the West we either live in or must live with.

Thanks once more to Jan Oberg at Transnational Foundation for Peace & Future Research for alerting me to a splendid dissection, of her latest display of breath taking ignorance and stupidity, by Shane Fitzgerald on his Truth & Balance substack.

Kaja Kallas Claims ‘Nobody Has Ever’ Attacked Russia and It has No Security Concerns

Europe’s highest diplomat proving once again she is always part of the problem, never the solution, and that she is pathologically averse to the diplomacy her job requires.

Speaking to journalists after the Informal European Council summit in Dublin on the 13th of November, Kaja Kallas, the EU’s High Representative for Foreign Affairs and Security Policy, said:

‘If we start to talk about what Russia is asking regarding the security architecture, we actually walk into the traps that Russia is setting us, which is that we divert the attention away from that there is no ceasefire and actually start to listen to their claims. Let us focus on what it is at hand; we have one aggressor and one victim. And the aggressor does not have security concerns, and nobody has ever attacked them. They have attacked others. I mean, keep the focus, people.’

There are two very sizeable claims here.

The first is: ‘nobody has ever attacked them.’

We may interpret this in two ways. Perhaps, Kallas means that Ukraine didn’t attack Russia to initiate the present war because it was the other way around with Russia first invading Ukraine.

Putin’s address announcing the military operation on February 24th, 2022, formally submitted to the UN by Russia’s ambassador, Vassily Nebenzia, explicitly invokes Article 51 of the UN Charter citing the right to self-defence. The People’s Republic of Donetsk and the People’s Republic of Lugansk ‘asked Russia for help’. Thus, according to the Kremlin’s reasoning, Russia did not ‘attack’ Ukraine, but instead came to the defence of the Donbas republics at their official request. Given the Donbas War that lasted from 2014 to 2022 and the loss of life as the Ukrainian central state attempted to bring the two statelets to heel, Russia’s claim cannot be simply dismissed.

But is this what Kallas means? Or by ‘nobody has ever attacked them’ does she mean that no one has ever attacked Russia?

With a more sober-minded, less ideologically-driven diplomat, one would chalk it up to the vagaries of the moment and the ambiguities of the English language. But with Kaja Kallas, it’s impossible to dismiss the larger claim. Then, when we add in the fact that she has a long and consistent history of making large, sweeping unequivocal claims about Russia that cover centuries, then it’s very possible that the latter seems perfectly accurate in the mind of Europe’s top diplomat.

If she does indeed mean the latter, then this is yet one more piece of evidence, if it were needed, which it’s not, that Kallas is fit for office neither by nature, nor by acumen, nor by historical knowledge.

In case she does in fact mean to make the second claim, which is quite likely, here is a brief summary of the countries that have attacked Russia over the past 226 years.

In 1812, Napoleon’s France invaded Russia with troops from Prussia, Austria and the Duchy of Warsaw involved, among other states.

During the Crimean War (1853–1856), Britain, France, the Ottoman Empire and the Kingdom of Sardinia attacked both Russian territory and Russian forces.

During the Russian Civil War (1918–1920), the United States, Britain, France, Japan and Canada intervened militarily on Russian territory.

In 1941, Nazi Germany invaded the Soviet Union, supported by forces from Romania, Finland, Hungary, Italy, Slovakia and the Independent State of Croatia.

This equates to some 16–17 states that have attacked Russia over the past 226 years, in its incarnation as the Russian Empire or as the Russian Soviet Federative Socialist Republic (SFSR) within the larger Soviet Union, within which the Russian republic was the driving force. It should be remembered that these cases are complex and also that there are many others that I have excluded but which may constitute genuine assaults on Russian territory. However, I have gone with full unambiguity as much as possible.

Play it any way you like, if Kaja Kallas, the top diplomat in the European Union, really does mean to suggest that Russia has never been attacked, it is a monumentally bogus claim.

Her second claim is equally bizarre. It is also pretty self-defeating if Kallas had a genuine intention of putting herself forward as one of the chief negotiators for the EU.

Here is the claim: ‘the aggressor does not have security concerns.’

Yet again, there is some ambiguity. We may cut Kallas a little slack for this owing to it being an interview and not an official European statement. We may also cut her no slack at all. She is Europe’s most senior diplomat and Vice-President of the European Commission. Sweeping statements, intractable positions and vague indeterminacies are really not becoming of the style of communication for people occupying such posts.

She may mean that Russia does not have security concerns at present. However, her language also clearly demonstrates that she sees Russia as a perennial aggressor spanning at least a century and never as a state that could ever be the victim of any military assault. She has, for instance, averred on multiple occasions that Russia has attacked more than 19 countries in the past 100 years whilst never explicitly revealing which countries she means. In the second reading, Kaja Kallas is saying that Russia can never have any legitimate security concerns, nor any right to them.

In the first interpretation, she reveals herself to be the problem so many think she is and never the solution to any difficulty.

The Russian Federation has for decades spoken of its vital security concerns and red lines. It has for decades maintained that an ever-expanding NATO represents an existential threat to it. Western officials and experts have for decades admitted so much and warned of the dire consequences of not accepting this fact. When a state says the same thing again and again for thirty years, believe it, for it is true. It is also true that only one state has a right to decide what represents a threat to Russia’s security and what doesn’t: Russia.

Ukraine’s membership in NATO and what it means for the Russian Federation has been at the heart of the present war from the start. But this also goes back to 2014 and the US-led coup that the Ukrainian state calls the Maidan Revolution. It also goes back to 2008 when Georgia and Ukraine were promised imminent membership in NATO, and Russia responded by moving to protect the breakaway regions of South Ossetia and Abkhazia and rolling up to Tbilisi before falling back almost immediately. This is a powerful state demonstrating in a restrained way that its red lines were being breached.

Kaja Kallas’s anchoring point for negotiations with Russia is to a priori castrate it of its most fundamental condition and any right to it – that Ukraine always remains neutral and never joins NATO. This is not diplomacy. Kallas is not a diplomat. This is not how negotiations between sides that want to solve complex issues work.

If we go with the second interpretation, that Russia never has security concerns because it is always a state that attacks and is never attacked, let us introduce this fact by way of rebuttal.

The largest invasion in history, Operation Barbarossa, was launched against the Soviet Union by Nazi Germany. Approximately 27 million citizens of the Soviet Union – 18 million civilians and 9 million soldiers – were killed during the whole of World War II. For comparison, the US lost 416,800 military personnel and 1,700 civilians.

If any state has a legitimate right to be worried about its security and a right to do what is necessary to make sure its borders are secure and its people are safe, it is Russia.

These statements by Kaja Kallas are yet more proof that she is always part of the problem, never the solution, and that she suffers from a pathological aversion to the very diplomacy her job necessitates.

*

I’ve replicated Shane Fitzgerald’s in full here but omitted the lively and for the most part well informed BTL comment on his Truth & Balance substack. Those who haven’t completely rid themselves of the widespread view, for which its major promulgators and beneficiaries have yet to offer a scintilla of evidence, that Russia threatens Europe and therefore its peoples must take further erosions of social welfare as living costs soar, for the further enrichment of ‘our’ military industrial complex, might usefully read that comment.

As well, of course, as my own Ukraine timeline (:-)

* * *

  1. The link on ‘Queen Ursula’ is to Politico, whose politics I do not share. All the same, this particular piece is one I approve for its detail and factuality.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *