Scattered minds: do I have ADHD? Part 1

27 Oct

All photos (bar one) by Rachael Morgan
*

A month ago, on September 25th, I took my partner of seventeen years to be my lawful wedded bride. There’d been no bending of knee. In fact it was Jackie who proposed to me, from the bed to which I’d brought her breakfast tray (a now daily routine detailed in the first stage is denial) she having led into the proposal with “this isn’t very romantic but …”

(One month earlier, and one day before we set off for WOMAD, Jackie had been diagnosed with lung cancer metastised in brain, throat, spine, liver and lymph nodes. Given the high likelihood of her ‘predeceasing’ me, and fearing for my future solvency on a state plus small corporate annuity, she wants me to have that portion of her pensions to which widowerhood would entitle me.)

Romantic or not, the ceremony at Sheffield Registry Office was deeply moving for all, 1 as was the wedding brunch eight days later, 2 at which, between main courses and champagne toast, my speech referred fleetingly to a daughter’s adamance on my exhibiting textbook signs of ADHD – adding, to laughter from our guests, that “this would explain a lot …”

Speaking of marriage, below (left) is my daughter Frances, sister to Annie and fiancée to Tara (right). Having lived happily together for over a decade, Fran and Tara will wed next summer in Madeira.

And speaking of Annie …

Here in the interests of balance are my two beautiful step-daughters, Charis (left) as Rhianna stands by Carl, her beautiful man:

 

So this post is not about Jackie, who has forbidden me from writing about her: beyond reporting on clinical aspects as they unfold, and on their practical as opposed to emotional consequences for her. Nor is it about our wedding. It’s about the earth shatteringly vital question: is I or isn’t I a man whose seventy-four spins round the sun have been taken in the company of the condition, thus far undiagnosed, known as ADHD – attention deficit hyperactivity disorder?

As chance would have it the reason daughter Annie settled so emphatically on this label is she recently read a book on it, Scattered Minds, by the Canadian physician Gabor Maté. Why invoke chance? A family likeness observed in a TV interview led me to look up Gabor’s namesake. His son Aaron is often cited in my posts: occasionally on Ukraine and Syria where he counters, with stubborn facts not entirely drowned out by the louder narratives of wealth and power, media instilled falsehoods of Putin waging unprovoked war in Ukraine 3 4 and Assad gassing his own people, 5 but for the most part in the context of a Gaza holocaust on which, like his Grayzone colleague Max Blumenthal – plus Jeffrey Sachs, Norman Finkelstein, Katie Halper, Zak Polanski and Alexei Sale, to name but a handful of Jewish anti-Zionists – Aaron Maté backs up with facts no less stubborn his denunciations of the murderously self proclaimed ‘Jewish State’.

I mention this not for novelty value but because when you watch Aaron Maté podcasts – or his guest spots on such as Judge Andrew Napolitano, Electronic Intifada  and Katie Halper Show – he displays a grasp of facts as unnerving as it is impressive, together with the somewhat robotic delivery of a Finkelstein or Blumenthal; a commonality unattributable to Jewishness or its Israel-critical subset but, I now suspect, ADHD. Sure enough, Gabor Maté reveals in Scattered Minds  that all three of his children are, like dad, diagnosed as blessed and cursed with the condition. 6

As, says Annie, am I. For evidence of which she looks to two especially glaring indicators …

  • high intelligence in one arena – mastery of symbolic logic paired with verbal agility in its written forms – offset by obtuseness, naivity and indeed stupidity elsewhere;
  • an ability to focus to an obsessive degree on one or two areas of intense interest while displaying in all the others the inattentiveness and disconnect of a scattered mind. 7

… and one glaring antecedent:

  • A deeply traumatised and troubled childhood.

In part 2 I’ll seek, I trust without mechanistic or a-priori reductivity, to map these indicators to a review of Scattered Minds: the origins and healing of attention deficit disorder, 8 the better to answer the question posed earlier: is I or isn’t I ADHD positive?

* * *

  1. We wanted Louise Morgan, a dear friend and Renaissance Woman – baker, crime scene investigator, advocate for disabled access to the Great Outdoors, licenced Registrar and much besides – to preside over our wedding but, within the city limits, Sheffield will only allow its own Registrars, and we weren’t confident of Jackie being well enough to travel. In the event she could have made the trek to Wakefield but the female Registrar who did oversee things was almost as good as Louise would have been, combining efficiency with great sensitivity to our situation.
  2. Chapeau to Cornerstone, the venue in the Hunters Bar district of Sheffield. Chloe, Emma and the team came through for us big time; managing all of our advance requests, and serving sumptuous food with elegance and loving care in a venue made perfect by bright sun streaming through the skylights of its upper floor. (Of a shortlist of four, this was the first we inspected. By a unanimity of three, converted to five via cell phone exchanges of snaps, we agreed our search was already over.) In keeping with the pragmatic note struck at the start of this post, let me add that the bill was amazingly modest.
  3. By “media instilled”, I mean not only corporate news and heavily curated opinion, but the fuzzier propaganda of arts and entertainment. Just last night I was watching cartoonlike depictions of Russian and Chinese devilry – helped out by rotten apples amidst the upper echelons of Our Chaps – in Series 3 of the daft but enjoyable BBC thriller, Vigil. As with Syria, such screen caricatures build and, by a myriad tiny but interactive increments, daily reinforce those shared ideological understandings which prime us, without our needing to invoke conspiracy – nor yet, on matters vital to power, rule it out – for ‘our’ next war, be it latent or kinetic. And as with the subliminal messaging of commercial propaganda (the wall to wall advertising by which mendacity is so normalised its moral corrosions are no more visible to us than the air we breathe) we are rendered all the more susceptible for fondly deeming ourselves immune.
  4. In a post yesterday on his website – Trump is right: Zelensky “should have settled this war a long time ago” – Aaron Maté, while no admirer of the tangerine narcissist, charts the Democrats’ dirty dealings in the empire’s proxy war on Russia. For a more universal antidote to the “Putin’s unprovoked war” narrative see my post, A Ukraine timeline.
  5. Of my many posts on the dirty war on Syria in the name of democracy by Al Qaeda cut-out, the most comprehensive is a 2017 offering, Monbiot, Syria and universalism.
  6. Early in Scattered Minds, Maté discusses the related questions of: (a) defining ADHD by way of configurations of indicators, any one of which may be widespread or in milder form ‘normal’; (b) simplistically binary oppositions of ‘nature v nature’; (c) whether we are medicalising bad behaviour and in effect pleading diminished responsibility in ways that absolve individual agency however sociopathic. Speaking of sociopathy, neoliberalism’s market-deification inflicts such devastating loss in every aspect of our lives – from 24/7 surveillance and stolen rights, to plummeting insect populations and plastics in our seas and intestines – that we can’t rule out mental illness at pandemic levels.
  7. Other signs are low impulse control, of verbal anger especially, a trail of abandoned projects once initial passion is spent, and compulsive footnoting in blog posts …
  8. Maté the Elder wrote in 1999, at which point the term, attention deficit disorder, was still transitioning from its earlier three word form by addition of the h-word to give the now more widespread, attention deficit hyperactivity disorder.

15 Replies to “Scattered minds: do I have ADHD? Part 1”

  1. Phil, me auld cocksparrow… congratulations on following Jackie’s advice and tying the knot on those now not so loose purse strings, but why didn’t you give us a shout to join in and celebrate such a happy event.
    No seriously, all the best to both of you and to the rest of your family members. If you could, and I’m sure you would were it manageable, my offer of letting you stay in a comfy flat in Santa Cruz de Tenerife with a car is still on the table.
    Love on ya bro xx
    Jim

    • Re your first para, ours was an unusual wedding. We kept it small, which meant many dear friends, you included, didn’t get “a shout” on account of distance. With just one exception – the transcendental Rachael, de facto kin on Jackie’s side, for whom flying in from Copenhagen barely registers when “my work has me taking planes all the time” – everyone was from the north of England, mostly Yorkshire.

      As for your second, what a fantastic offer! It’s still not clear whether Jackie may fly, but rest assured your words are duly noted …

      Love on you too, my friend of nigh on six decades xx

  2. Congratulations Phil and Jackie!

    As ever your blogsite contains excellent pics – but on this occasion not by you Phil! Looks like a lovely occasion – you both seem to be enjoying yourselves!

    • Thanks Bryan – so sorry you couldn’t be there.

      The pictures by Rachael, sister in law to Renaissance Louise, are terrific. Those shown here I picked from a set of equally life-affirmative shots,

    • Thank you, John. In my now more constrained situation I don’t know when I’ll next get up to Scotland but you’ll be in my thoughts – and I will be following you in The Lobster!

  3. Hi Phil. I hope you and Jackie are proceeding just as well as is humanly possible under the deeply unfortunate circumstances. Best wishes to you all.

    As for “is I or isn’t I ADHD?” – who cares. It’s just a name for something which is part of the ‘human condition’, and really no more remarkable than being cheerful or moody, fat or thin, or introverted or extroverted. I mean it’s not as if you are B. Netanyahu! Generally, as you recount it above, I have a similar history to yours, although without the ‘social care’ bit, thank god. But you’ve got over all these obstacles to have a home, a family, a good personal relationship, and a realistic world view, – that makes up for a lot of minor deficiencies, which we all have.

    • Thanks for the kind words, Jams. I don’t rule out my being one of the Worried Well with a bee in his bonnet. I’m in a strange place and Jackie’s not wanting me to write about her inner states frees me to investigate my own. In any case Gabor Maté writes with great intelligence and clarity while drawing on a wealth of fascinating evidence, and what I said in my speech about ADHD “explaining a lot” wasn’t entirely in jest. What’s more my late teacher, a flawed but brilliant man who like all self anointed gurus of ‘enlightenment’ mistrusted psychoanalysis for its implication that even the Enlightened One may be blind to his own shadow – also said, wisely I think, that when we truly see ourselves we see the world.

      As in the entirety of the human condition.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *